Best Commercial Trucking Insurance Companies 2026
We evaluated 20+ carriers on coverage options, claims speed, financial stability, and owner-operator reviews.
Progressive Commercial
Best for: Owner-operators and small fleets
America's largest commercial auto insurer with competitive rates for all truck types.
Pros
- Lowest rates for many truck types
- Online quoting in minutes
- Excellent financial stability
- 24/7 claims support
Cons
- Limited agent network in rural areas
- Some coverage types require add-ons
Sentry Insurance
Best for: Mid-size and large fleets
Specializes in trucking insurance with dedicated trucking division and competitive fleet rates.
Pros
- Dedicated trucking specialists
- Competitive fleet discounts
- Strong claims team
Cons
- Higher minimums for new authorities
- Online quoting not available in all states
Old Republic Insurance
Best for: Long-haul operators and fleets
Long-standing trucking insurer with strong claims reputation and nationwide coverage.
Pros
- Strong claims handling reputation
- Nationwide coverage
- Specializes in trucking
Cons
- No online quoting — agent required
- Slower policy issuance
Canal Insurance
Best for: High-risk accounts and new authorities
Trucking specialist known for accepting high-risk and hard-to-place accounts.
Pros
- Accepts new authorities
- Covers hard-to-insure cargo types
- Flexible underwriting
Cons
- Higher premiums than standard carriers
- Agent-only access
Great West Casualty
Best for: Safety-focused carriers and fleets
Dedicated trucking insurer providing comprehensive coverage with a focus on safety.
Pros
- Strong safety programs
- Competitive rates for safe drivers
- 100% trucking focus
Cons
- Limited to agent-based quoting
- Stricter underwriting standards
National Interstate Insurance
Best for: Specialty transportation and niche truck types
Specializes in specialty transportation with flexible program options.
Pros
- Specialty vehicle expertise
- Flexible coverage programs
- Strong financial backing
Cons
- Limited direct-to-consumer access
- Higher premiums for small fleets
Get Free Trucking Insurance Quotes
Licensed agents. No spam. Response within 24 hours.
Request received!
A licensed agent will contact you within 24 hours.